I can't remember what show, but my husband was watching some show on TV and they mentioned Kafka or his works. The show mentioned (or maybe he looked into it afterwards) that Kafka can be very depressing, but there is also a slight humor to a lot of his works and an art in them. My husband, from the TV show, thought he might appreciate this humor- despite the tragic/depressing parts and rented some from the library. I have made a goal to be more well-read and to be more rounded in my choice of literature. So I started reading them as well. Franz Kafka was a Jew in Germany, who had a hard life, from what I have found. He may have died before the Jews faced their biggest trials in WWII, but thinking about it, I'm sure their persecution didn't start then. Kafka may have faced poverty, ridicule, any number of things, but his works, even when depressing have value and have lessons that can be learned from them.
The Judgment: This first story I'm not sure if I understood the point of it. It seems two people are affected by a tragedy and one thinks he is the only one moving on, and becomes quite selfish. The other one takes advantage of the first's complete obliviousness to things not concerning himself and prepares for the ruin of the first. The part I don't get is the second says he loves the first and then commands the first to drown himself, and then the willingness of the first to do so. Maybe the first WAS so selfish that the humiliation of NOT being able to achieve everything he thought was too much to live with. Whatever the case, I did not like it very much.
The Metamorphosis: My husband tells me that Franz Kafka himself got tuberculosis, but in the end died of starvation. At times I feel this story has some semblance of an autobiography. I did find most of it amusing- even if just the way he described certain things. Within the first paragraphs of the story you find that he has been changed into some sort of beetle and is on its back. I can picture a bug on its back struggling to get back upright, and although it is sad, the way he describes it makes the picture in my head seem quite funny. There are many things in this book. The need to fit in, feelings of being outcast, feeling useless, other themes as well.
In the Penal Colony: This one I also liked. It's based around a torture device that is very inhumane. To me it emphasizes many things, including the right to a fair trial. The need to be innocent until proven guilty instead of guilty first. Considering Kafka was a Jew, I read this one and actually thought of Hitler and the concentration camps. I related Hitler to the Old Commandant. But Kafka died in 1924- before Hitler and his concentration camps and persecution of the Jews (though I assume there had been persecution before, though different). It also, to me, emphasizes the need for us to stand up for things we believe in, that we feel are right, no matter how we feel they may be received.
The Great Wall of China: This one is an essay that starts out about building the wall of China. Then in the middle it talks about the citizens of China in the southeast (I believe). Then comes back to the wall of China. It wasn't my favorite story, but was well done, in that a German is a Chinese man, and from what I know of its citizens, is pretty accurate. It reminded me that the wall may have been, not only to keep Mongols out, but foreign influences, that were considered an enemy to and threat to the Chinese culture. I did like a quote in it: "Try with all your might to comprehend the decrees of the high command, but only up to a certain point; then avoid further meditation. A very wise maxim, which moreover was elaborated in a parable that was later often quoted: Avoid further meditation, but not because it might be harmful; it is not at all certain that it would be harmful. What is harmful or not harmful has nothing to do with the question. Consider rather the river in spring. It rises until it grows mightier and nourishes more richly the soil on the long stretch of its banks, still maintaining its own course until it reaches the sea, where it is all the more welcome because it is a worthier ally.--Thus far may you urge your meditations on the decrees of the high command.--But after that the river overflows its banks, loses outline and shape, slows down the speed of its current, tries to ignore its destiny by forming little seas in the interior of the land, damages the fields and yet cannot maintain itself for long in its new expanse, but must run back between its banks again, must even dry up wretchedly in the hot season that presently follows.--Thus far may you not urge your meditations on the decrees of the high command." (p. 136-137) I am one to "over-meditate" something, and therefore, I'm not sure if I completely agree, but I do agree with the logic behind this quote. I'll have to think more on it.
A Country Doctor: In this story, a country doctor is trying to save one person, but no one is willing to help the doctor. And then he ends up with two people that need his help in two different places, he can't fully help either one and ends up sick himself. If we don't take care of ourselves, we can't help anyone. And the tragic-ness of not being able to be in two places at once. The need for others to sometimes help- especially to one who probably has helped us or our families at one point or another.
A Common Confusion: I liked this story, and I feel most people can relate. It has to do with missing someone or an opportunity. But it also talked about being so busy that we miss something and the importance to make time for the important things. Really short story (a page and a half?). It refers to the two main people as A and B and the two destinations as H and home. One quote: "At home he [A] learns that B had arrived quite early, immediately after A's departure, indeed that he had met A on the threshold and reminded him of his business; but A had replied that he had no time to spare, he must go at once."
The New Advocate: Another really short story. This one seems a bit philosophical. It seems reminiscent of the great days with Alexander the Great and one blazing a trail to India. And then seems to say, all we need now is people who study books (specifically law books here).
An Old Manuscript: His second story where he is now a Chinese citizen. This one in its capital outside the Emperor's palace. It talks about foreigners within the city and I actually like the last quote, as a summary of the story. ""What is going to happen?" we all ask ourselves. "How long can we endure this burden and torment? The Emperor's palace has drawn the nomads here but does not know how to drive them away again. The gate stays shut; the guards, who used to be always marching out and in with ceremony, keep close behind barred windows. It is left to us artisans and tradesmen to save our country; but we are not equal to such a task; nor have we ever claimed to be capable of it. This is a misunderstanding of some kind; and it will be the ruin of us.""
A Fratricide: I liked this short story about a murder. It talks about a person who watches the whole thing but doesn't do anything about it. It reminds me of our need to be involved in things sometimes. There was a story once in New York where a girl was being stabbed and killed and yelling for help, yet no one stopped to help. Some people stood watching, but no one lifted a finger. I once heard someone speculate that today with youtube and our cell phones, we might stand there and videotape the event, thinking maybe we'll be the first one to report it and get fame, but no one would lift a finger to actually help and intervene. If we were in that situation, would we try and prevent a crime? Would we even take the time to call the police so someone else can help?
A Report to an Academy: I really liked this story about an ape who becomes human. I mean he still has fur, but he overcomes his ape side and becomes civilized. This story analyzes, not freedom, but the need to have some direction to move. Somewhere to go, even if there is no freedom to choose which way to go, one direction to move is good. It talks about the need for motivation to move and I think gives a good example of overcoming adversity, trials, flaws in our own character. In this, the ape is not resentful, but he does not look at his act of being civilized as right. He does not feel other apes should seek to do the same, in fact he feels pity for one chimp, but for him, he felt it was necessary and he does not regret what he did.
I have now finished and will try to finish giving brief summaries of the last few stories.
The Hunter Gracchus: Starts out very descriptive, almost felt like the beginning of a novel. It was short and curious. I don't know if I understood the intended message, but it's about a hunter who befalls some tragedy and then is cursed to roam the earth on a boat. Never able to linger long, not able to receive help or eternal rest. I kinda liked it, but it definitely wasn't my favorite.
A Hunger Artist: This one has to do with a man who fasts for a living. I want to say that Kafka died of starvation, but I could be wrong. Anyways, there are times when he seems to glorify fasting or starvation. This seems like one of those times, except the character dies at the end, very frail and pitiful. He wants to make a new record for fasting and insists he can go "one more day" until by death he is stopped. It talks of very many things relating to fasting, but it seems to miss the point for me. I realize Kafka was a Jew- so he did not believe in Christ's teachings as fact, but to me Christ tells us what fasting should be when he talks about how hypocrites fast and make sure people know it and it is for the glory of men and not for God's help as it should be. (St. Matthew chapter 6). In conclusion, I think this story helps emphasize what I have noticed as a trend of Kafka's to focus on fasting and starvation, but it wasn't my favorite.
Investigations of a Dog: I thought this had way too many side notes and didn't make one clear point. It seemed to me that his main investigation has to do with, once again, starvation. The dog thought he saw food that didn't fall to the ground but followed him through the air and pursued him. So he decides that he must starve himself to see if food will come to him. But when he first noticed this phenomena he was not starving, so why he felt the need to starve himself to try his experiment is beyond me, besides the fact that Kafka was intrigued by starving and/or fasting. It is very philosophical in nature and doesn't really reach any conclusions. Luckily the dog does not die, he is too tempted by food and therefore his experiment failed.
The Burrow: I'll admit, I think I spent too much time while reading this trying to figure out which animal, precisely, was being depicted. It doesn't much matter though. It talks of a safety net. It talks of a treasured area, and getting distracted, not thinking things through, allowing danger to enter, and then becoming to scared to think through things logically. I can relate in many ways, looking back on this story and although I didn't like it much while reading it, I think I like it more when thinking about the message it was trying to convey.
Josephine the Singer, or the Mouse Folk: This one insists that mice do not sing or like music, except for that which comes from Josephine. I kinda liked this one, though I'm not sure if I got the intended message. It talks of how she craves attention, wants to be listened to, feels her message is vital to all mice. It talks of how entranced all mice are with her voice, and spends a little bit of time going into how she may or may not make those sounds, that no other mouse can.
Overall I liked these stories. They weren't all intriguing, and so it wasn't the fastest read for me, but I feel there are good points in at least most of the stories, and good messages, even with the tragic, and sometimes weird endings.
Tuesday, May 29, 2012
Thursday, May 17, 2012
Messenger by Lois Lowry
Alright, so this book tied in The Giver and Gathering Blue together. There were magical aspects to the other two stories, like how memories were transferred in The Giver, and the second one with the gifts, but most of it seemed to be like every day life. This book however had more fantasy in it. People could trade a part of themselves for other things. I mean, yes, in real life, people sometimes give up a part of themselves to fit in, but physical traits don't change without going to a hair salon, tattoo artist or plastic surgeon. With that said, I still liked the book and the fact that it tied the other two together. I didn't really see a correlation to the first book from the second, and this one tied it in.
There was one quote towards the end that I really liked: "He saw Forest and understood what Seer had meant. It was an illusion. It was a tangled knot of fears and deceits and dark struggles for power that had disguised itself and almost destroyed everything. Now it was unfolding, like a flower coming into bloom, radiant with possibility." This whole book has to do with people being generally good, but fears and deceits can take over at times and bring out the worst in people. Struggling for more power can be evil and many other things. But I think this theme wraps up the message of this book.
I'll put in one more note: I wish she had figured out another way to end the book... For those who read it, you may understand what I mean, if you think as I do. I did think that the event was written well. I wasn't sad like I have been in other books when similar things happen.
There was one quote towards the end that I really liked: "He saw Forest and understood what Seer had meant. It was an illusion. It was a tangled knot of fears and deceits and dark struggles for power that had disguised itself and almost destroyed everything. Now it was unfolding, like a flower coming into bloom, radiant with possibility." This whole book has to do with people being generally good, but fears and deceits can take over at times and bring out the worst in people. Struggling for more power can be evil and many other things. But I think this theme wraps up the message of this book.
I'll put in one more note: I wish she had figured out another way to end the book... For those who read it, you may understand what I mean, if you think as I do. I did think that the event was written well. I wasn't sad like I have been in other books when similar things happen.
Sunday, May 13, 2012
Gathering Blue by Lois Lowry
This book I had thought would be a continuation of the first book, The Giver, but it was not. However, I started reading the third book in this series and within the first few chapters it has alluded to both The Giver and this book- so they do all come together.
This town is another "perfect" town. The books all seem to be based in the future, where humans have decided to control certain aspects of life in hopes of making life better. This one is in a village where physical flaws are looked down upon and often people are sent "to the fields" to die if they have an imperfection. The Elders of this town are in charge of everything and their history is recorded through a coat with woven threads, and on a staff and a person that sings the history once a year in remembrance of what has happened. In both The Giver and Gathering Blue, someone realizes there is a flaw in the way things are run and someone stays to try and change things for the better. I read this initially and although I enjoyed it, I enjoy it more knowing that in the third book things will hopefully all be tied together.
This town is another "perfect" town. The books all seem to be based in the future, where humans have decided to control certain aspects of life in hopes of making life better. This one is in a village where physical flaws are looked down upon and often people are sent "to the fields" to die if they have an imperfection. The Elders of this town are in charge of everything and their history is recorded through a coat with woven threads, and on a staff and a person that sings the history once a year in remembrance of what has happened. In both The Giver and Gathering Blue, someone realizes there is a flaw in the way things are run and someone stays to try and change things for the better. I read this initially and although I enjoyed it, I enjoy it more knowing that in the third book things will hopefully all be tied together.
Friday, April 20, 2012
The Bet by Anton Chekhov
This book is a very quick read. It centers around a bet as to whether capital punishment or life-imprisonment is more harsh. A guy volunteers to solitary confinement for 15 years. I was "assigned" to read this book by an Uncle who is an English teacher. He has his students read this story and then think of 10 books (trilogies are allowed as long as you can prove that they can be sold BOUND that way. As in hardcover sets, not ebook packages) they would take with them (as the only books they could read the rest of their life, whereas, in the book he is able to ask for an unlimited amount of books), 10 cd albums (not mixes, must be sold that way), and 10 movies. He also asks for 10 restaurants. I can't remember, from his assignment, if those were places you would be able to order from or go to during solitary confinement (or on the stranded island with you, if that's how you picture it) or if those are the only places you can go to once you get out. Either way, I thought it was an interesting read and I have started making my lists. Not that most readers will care what is on my list, but I'm going to record it here for my own sake. This is the current list:
Books:
1. The LDS scriptures (as a quad- includes the Old and New Testaments, the Book of Mormon, Doctrine & Covenants, The Pearl of Great Price, Topical Guide and Bible Dictionary)
2. Jesus the Christ by James E. Talmadge
3. The Lord of the Rings Trilogy by Tolkien (I own a collector's edition with all three)
4. The Gable Faces East by Anita Stansfield
5. Gables Against the Sky by Anita Stansfield
6. The Giver by Lois Lowry
7. Elantris by Brandon Sanderson
8. Warbreaker by Brandon Sanderson
9. His Dark Materials Trilogy (The Golden Compass, The Subtle Knife, The Amber Spyglass) by Philip Pullman)
10. Strengthening Our Families: An In-Depth Look at the Proclamation on the Family by David C. Dollahite
Movies:
1. 10 Things I Hate About You
2. Disney's Enchanted
3. Salt
4. Wild Hearts Can't Be Broken
5. Dhoom:2 (a Bollywood film)
6. Disney's The Little Mermaid
7. Disney's Beauty and the Beast
8. The Princess and the Frog
9. Tangled
10. Forever Strong
CD Albums:
1. Mariah Carey's Greatest Hits
2. Celine Dion: All the Way... A Decade of Song
3. Kelly Clarkson: The Collection
4. The Essential Michael Jackson
5. Shania Twain Greatest Hits
6. 50 Best Soprano Arias
7. Pussycat Dolls- PCD
8. Beach boys- Still Cruisin
9. Renee Olstead- Renee Olstead
10. Frank Sinatra- Nothing But the Best
Restaurants:
1. Mimi's Cafe
2. Olive Garden
3. Taco Bell
4. Zupa's
5. Little Caesar's
6. PF Chang's
7. Whiskey Grill (Mammoth, CA)
8. Red Lobster
9. Eggs 'n' Things (Thousand Oaks, CA)
10. Cheesecake Factory
Books:
1. The LDS scriptures (as a quad- includes the Old and New Testaments, the Book of Mormon, Doctrine & Covenants, The Pearl of Great Price, Topical Guide and Bible Dictionary)
2. Jesus the Christ by James E. Talmadge
3. The Lord of the Rings Trilogy by Tolkien (I own a collector's edition with all three)
4. The Gable Faces East by Anita Stansfield
5. Gables Against the Sky by Anita Stansfield
6. The Giver by Lois Lowry
7. Elantris by Brandon Sanderson
8. Warbreaker by Brandon Sanderson
9. His Dark Materials Trilogy (The Golden Compass, The Subtle Knife, The Amber Spyglass) by Philip Pullman)
10. Strengthening Our Families: An In-Depth Look at the Proclamation on the Family by David C. Dollahite
Movies:
1. 10 Things I Hate About You
2. Disney's Enchanted
3. Salt
4. Wild Hearts Can't Be Broken
5. Dhoom:2 (a Bollywood film)
6. Disney's The Little Mermaid
7. Disney's Beauty and the Beast
8. The Princess and the Frog
9. Tangled
10. Forever Strong
CD Albums:
1. Mariah Carey's Greatest Hits
2. Celine Dion: All the Way... A Decade of Song
3. Kelly Clarkson: The Collection
4. The Essential Michael Jackson
5. Shania Twain Greatest Hits
6. 50 Best Soprano Arias
7. Pussycat Dolls- PCD
8. Beach boys- Still Cruisin
9. Renee Olstead- Renee Olstead
10. Frank Sinatra- Nothing But the Best
Restaurants:
1. Mimi's Cafe
2. Olive Garden
3. Taco Bell
4. Zupa's
5. Little Caesar's
6. PF Chang's
7. Whiskey Grill (Mammoth, CA)
8. Red Lobster
9. Eggs 'n' Things (Thousand Oaks, CA)
10. Cheesecake Factory
Thursday, April 19, 2012
The Iron Knight by Julie Kagawa
SPOILER ALERTS:
So, I know I rated it 5 stars, but there were times when reading it when I hated it. Ariella comes back in the picture and Ash wavers in his devotion to Meghan. It made me feel like he only loved whomever he could see at the time. If you love Meghan, Ariella will stay in the past. At the same time, you hear Ariella's story and I DID feel bad for her. She loved Ash, and at times sacrificed her own feelings for the good of all of Faery- like Meghan did. But when it came down to it, Ash analyzed his feelings. Before, he didn't have to choose between Meghan and Ariella because Ariella was gone, and not an option. I feel like everyone SHOULD (not does) make sure that their spouse IS their one true love, and not just the next best thing because your first choice is unavailable.
In Ash's quest to find a soul, he learns what it is to be human. I thought it interesting the things the author decided to focus on- what, according to her IS humanity. I felt myself agreeing with most of it, but it was a topic I've never thought of before. I hope to have more time to contemplate the things brought up in this book.
It also goes through some of the twisted things Ash has done. It was a little sickening to know the nice, sweet things he did for the girls he didn't care about, and I don't remember him doing any of those things for Meghan. But then I saw Ash's remorse as he gained a conscience and regretted what he had done, and remembered he still has time to do nice things for Meghan. And then I also remembered him sending people to watch out for her and her family, and returning her dog to her, and realized he had done nice little things for Meghan.
I really liked that at the end, there were study questions provided. Fablehaven did the same thing and it makes it easy to use this book as a book club read, or just to ponder the book for yourself.
The questions are:
1. Ash begins his journey in The Iron Knight to keep a promise he made to Meghan Chase. How important is it to keep promises when circumstances change? Under what, if any, circumstances would you not keep a promise?
2. Ash and Puck have an intense relationship based on a friendship gone wrong. We might call them frenemies. Ash felt that Puck was responsible for Ariella's death in the past. Do you believe Ash was justified in making his vow to kill Puck? How would you handle having a close friend cause hurt to another friend, whether accidentally or on purpose?
3. In The Iron Knight, we learn of the many terrible things Ash has done in the past, including murder. How did learning the details of Ash's past affect your opinion of him? In real life, who do you believe deserves a second chance?
4. Through Ash's quest to gain a soul, The Iron Knight explores what it means to be human, to have humanity. What are the key qualities of being human? What traits do you value in yourself and your friends and family?
5. In the gauntlet, Ash, Puck, Ariella and Grimalkin face mirror images of themselves that represent their dark sides. Why is it important that they see what they might become? How does it help Ash to succeed in his quest? Why didn't Grimalkin's reflection fight with the others?
6. Ariella chooses to give up her life so that Ash can have a soul. How might that sacrifice affect Ash in the future? In real life, what kinds of sacrifices are worth making, and what might constitute going too far?
7. How does Puck change over the course of the story? Why do you think he chose to come with Ash and support him in his quest to win the woman whom Puck also loves? Who do you believe should be with Meghan and why?
8. One of the premises behind Julie Kagawa's faery world is that faeries exist and become more powerful when humans remember them, tell stories about them and dream of them. What kind of power do dreams and the imagination have on humankind? How are they important in our lives?
So, I know I rated it 5 stars, but there were times when reading it when I hated it. Ariella comes back in the picture and Ash wavers in his devotion to Meghan. It made me feel like he only loved whomever he could see at the time. If you love Meghan, Ariella will stay in the past. At the same time, you hear Ariella's story and I DID feel bad for her. She loved Ash, and at times sacrificed her own feelings for the good of all of Faery- like Meghan did. But when it came down to it, Ash analyzed his feelings. Before, he didn't have to choose between Meghan and Ariella because Ariella was gone, and not an option. I feel like everyone SHOULD (not does) make sure that their spouse IS their one true love, and not just the next best thing because your first choice is unavailable.
In Ash's quest to find a soul, he learns what it is to be human. I thought it interesting the things the author decided to focus on- what, according to her IS humanity. I felt myself agreeing with most of it, but it was a topic I've never thought of before. I hope to have more time to contemplate the things brought up in this book.
It also goes through some of the twisted things Ash has done. It was a little sickening to know the nice, sweet things he did for the girls he didn't care about, and I don't remember him doing any of those things for Meghan. But then I saw Ash's remorse as he gained a conscience and regretted what he had done, and remembered he still has time to do nice things for Meghan. And then I also remembered him sending people to watch out for her and her family, and returning her dog to her, and realized he had done nice little things for Meghan.
I really liked that at the end, there were study questions provided. Fablehaven did the same thing and it makes it easy to use this book as a book club read, or just to ponder the book for yourself.
The questions are:
1. Ash begins his journey in The Iron Knight to keep a promise he made to Meghan Chase. How important is it to keep promises when circumstances change? Under what, if any, circumstances would you not keep a promise?
2. Ash and Puck have an intense relationship based on a friendship gone wrong. We might call them frenemies. Ash felt that Puck was responsible for Ariella's death in the past. Do you believe Ash was justified in making his vow to kill Puck? How would you handle having a close friend cause hurt to another friend, whether accidentally or on purpose?
3. In The Iron Knight, we learn of the many terrible things Ash has done in the past, including murder. How did learning the details of Ash's past affect your opinion of him? In real life, who do you believe deserves a second chance?
4. Through Ash's quest to gain a soul, The Iron Knight explores what it means to be human, to have humanity. What are the key qualities of being human? What traits do you value in yourself and your friends and family?
5. In the gauntlet, Ash, Puck, Ariella and Grimalkin face mirror images of themselves that represent their dark sides. Why is it important that they see what they might become? How does it help Ash to succeed in his quest? Why didn't Grimalkin's reflection fight with the others?
6. Ariella chooses to give up her life so that Ash can have a soul. How might that sacrifice affect Ash in the future? In real life, what kinds of sacrifices are worth making, and what might constitute going too far?
7. How does Puck change over the course of the story? Why do you think he chose to come with Ash and support him in his quest to win the woman whom Puck also loves? Who do you believe should be with Meghan and why?
8. One of the premises behind Julie Kagawa's faery world is that faeries exist and become more powerful when humans remember them, tell stories about them and dream of them. What kind of power do dreams and the imagination have on humankind? How are they important in our lives?
Tuesday, April 17, 2012
The Iron Queen by Julie Kagawa
Alright, so as I have continued reading this series they have become less like Twilight and something of their own. Well that is, despite the two guy interests- the cold one is of course, the forbidden one and as much as part of me would like to cheer for Puck (or Jacob in Twilight) I find myself cheering for the cold, forbidden one in both cases. In these books I feel Meghan is less flighty than Bella and more sure of what she wants.
For parents trying to screen books for their kids- their is a sex scene in this book- I thought it was tasteful. They start out kissing- lay down, then it talks about their auras danced and merged into one. If that left any doubt for you- she has to look for her clothes just a few pages later. The kissing scenes in this series are similar, in my opinion, to those in Twilight.
One part I especially liked was from Puck. Meghan and Ash are in some small fight and Puck says, ""Trouble in paradise , princess?" I felt my face heat, and Puck shook his head. "Well, don't drag me into it. I learned long ago that you don't get in the middle of a lover's spat. Nothing ever goes as planned-- people fall in love with the wrong person, someone ends up with a donkey head, and then it's a whole big mess."" I like how the author used "A Midsummer Night's Dream" to interpret a lesson she thought Puck had learned from that story and incorporated it into her own story.
For parents trying to screen books for their kids- their is a sex scene in this book- I thought it was tasteful. They start out kissing- lay down, then it talks about their auras danced and merged into one. If that left any doubt for you- she has to look for her clothes just a few pages later. The kissing scenes in this series are similar, in my opinion, to those in Twilight.
One part I especially liked was from Puck. Meghan and Ash are in some small fight and Puck says, ""Trouble in paradise , princess?" I felt my face heat, and Puck shook his head. "Well, don't drag me into it. I learned long ago that you don't get in the middle of a lover's spat. Nothing ever goes as planned-- people fall in love with the wrong person, someone ends up with a donkey head, and then it's a whole big mess."" I like how the author used "A Midsummer Night's Dream" to interpret a lesson she thought Puck had learned from that story and incorporated it into her own story.
Monday, April 16, 2012
The Giver by Lois Lowry
To anyone who hasn't read this book- I would recommend it :)
I had read this book in Elementary School, but recently found out it's part of a series. I couldn't remember this book well enough to write a review or to read a second book, if the story continues.
I loved this book. It is placed in the future, where apparently the human race decides to make things better by going to what they call "Sameness". The Receiver is the one person who holds all the memories from the past, so that when making new rules and decisions- someone can have the wisdom to try and make the best decision based on the past. When they pick a new Receiver, the old Receiver calls himself the Giver- since he is giving his memories to the new Receiver.
Through all these memories they are able to discuss different emotions, natural phenomena, and other issues without being preachy about any one issue or topic. It is very well written so as to make us all think about the importance of different things. For example- what good is war? Why should we judge based on hair color or skin color? Should we be tied to emotions? It doesn't answer those questions, but it brings so many issues up for the reader to think about and come to their own conclusion. I guess, in one sense it does answer the question, because both the Giver and the Receiver wish to make some drastic changes in the community and revert back in some ways.
SPOILER ALERT: Throughout the book they talk about Elsewhere. Old people and sometimes infants are released from the community and the people are told they go "Elsewhere". If they commit three major crimes (according to the community) they are also released. And here I'm going to talk about the end of the book- so stop reading if you don't want to know anything about the end. The boy tries escaping the communities. Him and the Giver believe that there is still a place where Elsewhere exists, and that people may still live outside the communities and the Sameness. At the end of the book, the boy is tired, barely still going and holding on. It ends hopeful, and the last time I read it I took that to mean that there was people in Elsewhere. But this time I found a new possibility. When the community would "release" someone and send them to "Elsewhere" it meant that they were killed. So this time reading the book I realized that the boy accomplished his goal/mission and it's possible that the last experience in the book is really him dying- similar to the community's way of releasing people, instead of reaching an Elsewhere that the people assumed people were being sent to. I still would like to believe that there were people living outside the Sameness communities, that he lived and survived, and maybe the next books will tell us, though I don't think they follow the same boy. From the brief summary of the next book I believe it is a story of the community and how they may hopefully start to change for the better. I guess we'll see. :)
I had read this book in Elementary School, but recently found out it's part of a series. I couldn't remember this book well enough to write a review or to read a second book, if the story continues.
I loved this book. It is placed in the future, where apparently the human race decides to make things better by going to what they call "Sameness". The Receiver is the one person who holds all the memories from the past, so that when making new rules and decisions- someone can have the wisdom to try and make the best decision based on the past. When they pick a new Receiver, the old Receiver calls himself the Giver- since he is giving his memories to the new Receiver.
Through all these memories they are able to discuss different emotions, natural phenomena, and other issues without being preachy about any one issue or topic. It is very well written so as to make us all think about the importance of different things. For example- what good is war? Why should we judge based on hair color or skin color? Should we be tied to emotions? It doesn't answer those questions, but it brings so many issues up for the reader to think about and come to their own conclusion. I guess, in one sense it does answer the question, because both the Giver and the Receiver wish to make some drastic changes in the community and revert back in some ways.
SPOILER ALERT: Throughout the book they talk about Elsewhere. Old people and sometimes infants are released from the community and the people are told they go "Elsewhere". If they commit three major crimes (according to the community) they are also released. And here I'm going to talk about the end of the book- so stop reading if you don't want to know anything about the end. The boy tries escaping the communities. Him and the Giver believe that there is still a place where Elsewhere exists, and that people may still live outside the communities and the Sameness. At the end of the book, the boy is tired, barely still going and holding on. It ends hopeful, and the last time I read it I took that to mean that there was people in Elsewhere. But this time I found a new possibility. When the community would "release" someone and send them to "Elsewhere" it meant that they were killed. So this time reading the book I realized that the boy accomplished his goal/mission and it's possible that the last experience in the book is really him dying- similar to the community's way of releasing people, instead of reaching an Elsewhere that the people assumed people were being sent to. I still would like to believe that there were people living outside the Sameness communities, that he lived and survived, and maybe the next books will tell us, though I don't think they follow the same boy. From the brief summary of the next book I believe it is a story of the community and how they may hopefully start to change for the better. I guess we'll see. :)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)